I have described conversations as one person in a group having an idea and everyone else in the group responding to that idea; then the next person in the group having an idea and everyone else in the group responding to that idea, and so on.
You may reply that conversations don’t actually occur in the way I’ve described. For example, in a group of 12 people maybe one person has an idea, and only two have a response. I would argue that everyone in the group has an idea, and everyone has a response. But that some don’t give voice to either.
That brings me to an idea I’ve been wrestling with for years: the talk dancer.
The talk dancer is someone who brings everyone in the group onto the conversational dance floor. He is able to fill an uncomfortable silence with an interesting idea or question that provokes conversation without dominating it; he is able to make those present feel safe enough to participate, and draw ideas or responses from those who are reticent.
For a group to thrive it needs a talk dancer.
I think one of the problems with dividing a group is that if one half does not have a talk dancer, then chances are that the half without a talk dancer will wither and die. And because talk dancers are such stimulating people to be around, everyone wants to be in the talk dancer’s group.
Moreover I think talk dancers are drawn to other talk dancers because they both share a love for good conversation. If the group divides, the talk dancers will probably want to be in the same group. So to add insult to injury, when the group divides one group will likely have all the talk dancers, while the other group has none.
I have not quite figured out how to deal with this dilemma. I’ve thought about having a secret ballot, and have each person in the group nominate the other persons in the group they think are talk dancers, then have the two with the most votes separate to form new groups. Or perhaps rank everyone in the group, and sort the odds into one group and the evens into another. But I’ve never put these ideas to the test.